Reviews

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

Bink & Gollie


Title: Bink & Gollie

Series: Bink & Gollie

Genre:  Early/Easy Reader

Author: Kate DiCamillo and Alison McGhee

Illustrator: Tony Fucile

Publisher: Candlewick Press

Publication Date: September 14, 2010

ISBN: 076363266X

Awards: 2011 Theodor Seuss Geisel Award;

2011 ALA Notable Children’s Books, Younger Readers;

Children's Book Committee Bank Street College of Education Best Children's Books of the Year 2011, Humor, ages 5-9;

Kirkus Reviews 2010 Best Children’s Books; Publishers Weekly Best Children’s Books 2010, Fiction;

NY Times Best Illustrated Children's Books of 2010

Plot: The sock shopping, pancaking eating, mountain climbing, roller skating adventures of Bink ( along with her fish named Fred) and Gollie.

Audience: Age Level: 6 and up, Grade Level: 1 and up

Uses: This is a great book for an eager early reader to expand their horizons. It would also be good for reading aloud in a classroom or library as long as one shares the delightful illustrations. It's a nice book to illustrate that the best of friends can look and act completely differently and still be holding hands at the end of the day.

Simple Concept: The book is a collection of three stories and both the story “title” and the first word of the first story are simple and easy to read.  Each progressive story is more intricate but the concept of two friends making plans is clear in each story.

Character Introduction:  Bink and Gollie are introduced in the very first line of the story.

Setting Introduction:  The title page features the homes of Bink and Gollie, and the town setting is quickly introduced.

Words per line: The lines have no more than ten words each, but some of the words are doozies.

Sentence Structure: Sentence span lines and often take two or three to complete. The structure is not overly simplistic.

 Action: There are multiple action scenes on each page both in text and in illustration.

Appealing Repetition:  Through the three stories there is a continuity of Bink’ striped socks which she purchases, much to Gollie’s dismay, in the first story.   There are very few word sequence repetitions.

Context for new words: There are some context clues for the extremely long early reader words, but not enough to completely explain them all, especially when more than one appears in a sentence.

Print: The print is in a clean, uncluttered font but it not overly large.

White Space:  There is plenty of white space for the eye to rest. 

Illustrations: The illustrations are mostly in black and white with pops of color.  They do give clues to the accompaning text.  For example a giant bin of socks accompanies the phrase, “It’s a sock bonanza.”

Strengths: Very funny, charming tale of two friends.  The humorous artwork engages the reader and helps pull them along the narrative.  The book offers some new vocabulary for the child reader and dry humor for the adult listener/reader.

Weaknesses: While these new words area welcome addition to any child’s vocabulary; they are in no way easy to read.  Words like outrageous; Tasmania; implore, extraordinary, and accomplishment mean that an adult needs to be within easy reach for the child to really understand the text.

Read Alikes: George and Martha series (1974) James Marshall; Zelda and Ivy series (1998) Laura McGee Kvasnosky; Calvin and Hobbs series by Bill Watterson








No comments:

Post a Comment